Your Baby Has Decided Something Already ~ Can you see?

August 3, 2012 · 6 comments

in Caring With Respect, Infant Care, Inspiration, Our "View" of Babies, Relationship


they say that the beginning
is marked by birth

never mind what you were doing for ten long months
tucked inside your mother’s core

they want to swaddle you, pass you, restrain you, decide for you
but it was you who decided something already

this morning you looked at a ray of sun

illuminating your own hand

there were no flashcards, no claps of approval
to choreograph this relationship with light

in a few months, a rattle will be used
you will be asked to smile, to coo, to say hello
“Good job, Henry!” “Good boy, Henry!” Good boy!”

is this when we begin to live life for others?
does it begin with a name? a certificate? a swaddle?
does it begin with the toy shoved in the palm of a hand
underneath the morning light? ~ Leyla Momeny

Leyla, who is a public school teacher in San Francisco, penned this poem while waiting at the airport for her flight home after completing the RIE Foundations Summer Intensive Course in Los Angeles. I’m thrilled to be able to share her thoughts with you. This is the first in what I hope will be a series of reflections from parents, care-givers, students and others who are putting Magda Gerber’s RIE philosophy into practice in “real life.” My hope is that by sharing the voices and experiences of a diverse group, we can illuminate ways in which respectful care-giving can benefit babies and adults, and strengthen families. What does respectful care look and sound like? What are the challenges, the questions, the joys, of caring for or parenting babies and toddlers in this way?

Leyla says, “I discovered RIE when my daughter was seventeen months old. It was a wonderful discovery and incredibly thought-provoking and trans-formative. I like to think that my girl has experienced the benefits of RIE, even at a “late” start. It is such a powerful framework for parenting and I can’t think of anything as beautiful and respectful as Magda Gerber’s notion of “wants nothing” time.


“Be careful what you teach the child, you may interfere with what he is learning. Once, many years ago, I saw a child lying on the floor trying to catch something in a very dreamy, beautiful way.  I did not see anything, but I knew that the child saw something.  Only as I walked around did I realize that the dust in the air was creating a rainbow and that is what the child saw.  That stayed with me as a symbolic reminder so that now when people do things, I want to say, ‘That child may just see that rainbow—don’t interrupt, Wait.’ ” ~ Magda Gerber

“Some days, the “RIEness” of my household is plainly evident: expressions of emotion are respected, play is not parent-directed, interactions are cooperative, autonomy is encouraged and respected, and boundaries are lovingly firm. This isn’t always the case, but it is what my husband and I strive for.

There are certainly challenges to parenting with this approach. People might think you’re a bit wacky. Other parents might wonder why you aren’t jumping up and down with earth-shattering delight and infectious enthusiasm when your child scales a challenging climbing structure or generously hands a coveted toy over to a new friend. It is difficult to communicate your belief in protecting and valuing a toddler’s intrinsic motivation, in thirty seconds or less, to another busy parent across the sandbox!

I have many, many questions, too. I am a new and humble student of RIE and feel I’ve made many “mistakes” in the past with this parenting thing. It’s all a process! What I have learned through studying Magda Gerber’s work is this: Infants are competent, autonomous beings. There is a difference between doing things TO THEM vs. WITH THEM. From day one, it is possible to cooperate with infants. There are specific steps to this such as always explaining what you are doing when diapering, feeding, or bathing. I’ve learned to slow down and to wait; to follow an infant’s cues. The pace most of us go at is a rushed, frenetic pace that can be anxiety-inducing to babies. Slowing down and touching and responding with great respect and care is a place to start.”



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


Kayla August 9, 2012

“there were no flashcards, no claps of approval
to choreograph this relationship with light”

That… is masterfully crafted. I love the way the words illustrate the light upon a child’s hand and the focus of the way light plays. Thank you so much for sharing the words from Leyla. It really does make a very strong and gorgeous point of how much a child is not to be molded but to be allowed to thrive and flourish.

I fully agree with the concept of working WITH THEM as opposed to against them. I struggle with this daily with my stepchildren. While much of it is following the guideline of the biological parents, much of it is also my own need for a paradigm shift. It’s a lot harder than it looks! I have been conditioned to control and bribery. I lapse in that often. I’m frequently lazy, whereas they are seeking true sense of trust and freedom in the most intense and overwhelming way.

Some of it is also that these kids were raised for the most part apart from me. They are 8, 10, and 12. I have known the youngest for all of her life.

Again, thank you for sharing. It truly helps my mind to make connections in changing my own way of thinking and observing different perspectives that supports these children in their times of difficulty. 🙂

Nina August 25, 2012

Great thoughts on Magda Gerber’s approach. I read her book a while ago and appreciated almost all of it. I especially love how practically each moment in a kid’s life is purposeful, even if to us it’s something simple as, like you say, staring at dust and rainbows.

Christine Schreier September 8, 2012

I vividly remember a little deaf friend about one year old at the time, excitedly alerting me to something she saw close to an electrical outlet on a otherwise bare and empty white wall while we were walking between two houses. Over and over her little hand went up to point it out to me and to make sure I also would be able to partake in her discovery. Her face and whole demeanor indicating udder delight in what she was able to see. I was very sad, because I knew I had lost the sight and connection she still had in which I could not share anymore. My only delight was her delight. Precious moments, now about 15 years in the past, but still very much with me.

{ 3 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: